← Feed
#Math #AI 15/n
The outcome of this reflection is that I am very skeptical of everything that comes from the LLM world.
What this summer taught me is that I was partly wrong.
But this morning, bang!, I was informed by a friend of a paper that appeared on September 4th on the database of mathematical publications, by three prominent algebraic geometers, Lev Borisov, Ofer Gabber and Adrian Vasiu, entitled “On endomorphisms of affine spaces and the Jacobian problem”. This 176-page (!) paper is precisely devoted to counterexamples to the Jacobian conjecture and to various companion conjectures in commutative algebra.
As is often the case in mathematical papers, it ends with an AI statement that says that no AI was used, nor were any of their results computer-based nor suggested by computer-generated data. But one of the authors, Vasiu, adds a puzzling paragraph where he explains that an earlier version of the file (from January 2025) had accidentally been made accessible on the Internet (I could explain how such things happen), and he says that he believes that its content had leaked to the database of material that AI companies use for generating texts. Indeed, on July 23, some AI could produce a 37-page that makes a detailed comparison between Alpöge's example and the theory of Borisov-Gabber-Vasiu as explained in the leaked version of their work.
On the opposite, the disproof of the Jacobian conjecture published by ulam.ai
(https://www.ulam.ai/research/jacobian.pdf)
on the basis of Alpöge's tweet contains no reference to any serious bibliography, and nothing of Borisov-Gabber-Vasiu.
https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.05746
Replies (2)
-
#Math #AI 16/n
I needed several toots to tell this story of the Jacobian conjecture that ran from July 19th to September 4th, but the story doesn't stop here!
One month later, Alpöge published a counterexample to another conjecture, and also a longer text building a complex structure on the 6-dimensional sphere. I have not much to say about them. The first one is presented on the form of a tweet, while the second one takes the form of a long paper, that starts with something that looks like some genuine mathematical insight, but the text lacks a proper introduction that would explain where the idea comes from, whether there had been earlier attempts in a similar vein, etc.
On August 1st, another company, Open AI released a paper “Ten advances in mathematics and theoretical computer science” giving a proof of 10 new results in several areas of mathematics. Most of them seem to be optimization of existing work, but some look genuinely new. Still, the writing is often inadequate, with a much too strong emphasis being put on the proven results.
Open ##5153665
-
@antoinechambertloir@mathstodon.xyz Regarding 15/ N, that's news to me and would be insane if true. Maybe it is coping, but I can only hope that was, indeed, what happened.
Open ##5153711