Elektrine lite

← Feed

@frankPodmore@slrpnk.net

2026-04-28 13:13 UTC

>Trade within itself doesn’t improve anyone’s life. It does; it improves the life of the two (at minimum) people trading. >What improves people’s lives is availability of jobs and services ... which depend upon trade... >(along with other factors) ... like GDP! >If you’re Apple, you sell bunch of phones in Mexico, produce them in China and reinvest earnings in EU, your sale counts to US GDP but doesn’t meaningfully influence lives of US citizens Yes, it does; it directly improves the lives of the people in the US who work for Apple and of their families, and also of Apple's shareholders in the US and elsewhere (perhaps, like me, you don't find yourself overly concerned with the quality of life of Apple's shareholders, but they are people and Apple's sales do improve their lives, and that is what is in question); indirectly, it improves the lives of the various other people that the employees and shareholders buy from and sell to. >t was completely different 100 years ago when all of the supply chain was within US and resulted in creation of wealth, jobs and products all contained within US borders This has never been the case for almost any country anywhere in the world, but *especially* not for the US, which has always had a complex economy relying on global trade. Indeed, the US wouldn't exist at all without international trade; it would have been impossible for colonialism to happen at all if foreign trade didn't profit individuals along the supply chain.

Replies (1)

  • @Semjeza@fedinsfw.app 2026-04-29 00:55

    I suspect that what the person you replied to, meant with "meaningfully improve the lives of US citizens" was that the amount Apple contributes to the GDP of the USA (odd, since much of the goods aren't domestically produced) is disproportionately high compared to its impact on quality of life of people in the US as a whole. While I'm sure most Apple employees are paid slightly above the median wage, I don't know the median salary for an Apply employee. I also, like you, am not utilitarian enough to think that a handful of people living large in opulence makes up for the way inequality is harming living standards and the economy as whole (not to mention the impact of it all on the planet). Additionally, Apple and large companies don't buy from, or in most cases sell to individuals. They buy and sell mostly to other companies and only at the end do smaller branches or franchises sell to actual people. Mostly you have numbers and goods moving between old fashioned AIs running on human-processing power, but not actual people. * P.S. Colonialism didn't begin with international trade, because the colonies were part of the colonising nation. They begin with murder, exploitation, and appropriation of conquered territory - trade could only happen once the formerly free regions were given a colonist government with sovereignty apart from the colonist home nation. And most of them were also just corporations originally too; and many who went were coerced either directly (by violence or law) or indirectly (by economics).

    Open ##1843004