Elektrine lite

← Feed

@antoinechambertloir@mathstodon.xyz

2026-09-10 09:14 UTC

#Math #AI 8/n - there are also lists of possibly easier problems, the kind of those should be accessible as soon as you have a basic knowledge of a small are of mathematics. There are even problems that are thought of as accessible, meaning that a professional mathematician who knows a moderate sample of the bibliography should be able to solve them. This makes possible to have an ongoing science, with incremental successes. Many PhD theses are of this kind which I find regrettable, meaning that a professional mathematician is often in position to solve it before the apprentice mathematician even could—only ethics and communication can prevent that. - Finally, prizes, medals, journal rankings, institution rankings, academic positions etc. that assess (and distort) in real time the scientific value that mathematicians give to individual achievements.

Replies (2)

  • #Math #AI 9/n Already several years ago, AI companies have decided to enter the game of mathematics. Their official motivation (I quote from memory one of the Google Deepmind leaders, last year at Leiden) is to provide us with new tools. But sometimes, the word escapes them that they wish to simply “solve mathematics”. It should be made clear that in no way can anybody “solve mathematics”. What is possible is solving a given mathematical question, or more likely, proving something related to a given mathematical question that the mathematical community views as an advance towards that question. Once a problem is solved, new problems emerge, either because the earlier question now makes it possible to set, or because we naturally turn our eyes to something else. Mostly, solving a question indicates that some mathematical tools are powerful and we wish to try those tools on questions that we feel could be addressed with them. What is also possible is “disrupting mathematics” by disrupting the fragile equilibrium of the field, as a sociological construct. But they wouldn't want to do that, would they?

    Open ##5153658

  • @gthm@mathstodon.xyz 2026-09-11 21:23

    @antoinechambertloir@mathstodon.xyz "Many PhD theses are of this kind which I find regrettable" Oh? Why? My view of a PhD is as an apprenticeship in a field. From that point of view this is a very natural thing to propose in a PhD thesis, and to cultivate. You want a fertile garden from which the next flowers can bloom.

    Open ##5153729