Elektrine lite

← Feed

@mxchara@cyberpunk.lol

2026-08-25 05:06 UTC

@memewarrior@hear-me.social Thank you! well, there's always room for improvement. That's a journey which may...toil on upwards towards the light, along a road one may never see the end of, if I may paraphrase Ursula LeGuin. I am struggling with the Nietzsche passage because even though he's hitting this eugenicist wall as it were, this fixed assumption that must have prevailed throughout the Western intellectual world. That stuff was once considered mainstream. So yeah, it's distasteful and over the edge. But I still feel like there's a glimmer of an actual phenomenon here, that he's not just off the rails. There is definitely a kind of weaponized or marketed "pity" which behaves just as Nietzsche describes and which is wielded for eugenicist purposes. Oh dear. Do you suppose there's a lot of Ayn Rand fans very very fond of this particular little snippet of Nietzsche? They do love their intellectual samplers and assortments in the "intellectual dark web".

Replies (3)

  • @mxchara@cyberpunk.lol @memewarrior@hear-me.social from what I can tell lesswrong cultists are too illiterate and stembrained to address continental philosophy in good faith. also Nietzsche was extremely critical of utilitarianism, which appears to be the dominant normative ethical view on lesswrong

    Open ##5122875

  • @memewarrior@hear-me.social 2026-08-25 05:44

    @mxchara@cyberpunk.lol H.L. Mencken liked them so much that he projected his own anti-Semitism onto The Antichrist despite the book praising Judaism when compared to Christianity. Mencken also had ties to Rand. Mencken's translation of the book says in the translator's preface: "The case against the Jews is long and damning; it would justify ten thousand times as many pogroms as now go on in the world." This translation also contains numerous errors, like translating "Schlecht"(bad) as "evil" when despite the entire first essay of The Genealogy of Morality being about the differences between "Good & Evil" & "Good & Bad". Reputable translations aren't any less eugenicist than Mencken's though. That is in the original text, not just bad translations. Rand wrote to Mencken, in 1934: "I hope you will understand my hesitation in writing to one whom I admire as the greatest representative of a philosophy to which I want to dedicate my whole life" according to Wikiquote.

    Open ##5122876

  • @memewarrior@hear-me.social 2026-08-25 05:45

    @mxchara@cyberpunk.lol So, someone Ayn Rand was a fan of. Does that count as an Ayn Rand Fan?

    Open ##5122878