Elektrine lite

← Feed

@Ek-Hou-Van-Braai@piefed.social

2026-10-16 17:36 UTC

Linus Torvalds shares his thoughts on Anti-AI coding rules

Replies (40)

  • @wesker@lemmy.sdf.org 2026-10-16 17:41

    I just want to say I was here before the downvoting started.

    Open ##5065578

  • @eestileib@sh.itjust.works 2026-10-16 18:04

    Strangely idgaf about whether he respects me

    Open ##5065988

  • @Mihies@programming.dev 2026-10-16 18:08

    This is really an ignorant and arrogant take at AI.

    Open ##5066054

  • @soratoyuki@piefed.zip 2026-10-16 18:29

    Genuine question. I’m not a developer, I didn’t study computer science, and I’m a pretty basic Fedora user. But why does everyone harp on Linus Torvald’s opinions like they’re handed down from heaven? Windows still dominates the market, but no one cares what Bill Gates says. I love A Song of Ice and Fire but I wouldn’t take writing tips from George R. R. Martin. Richard Stallman’s opinions on GNU/Linux are memed endlessly. Linus is literally just a dude.

    Open ##5066459

  • @bantering@lemmy.zip 2026-10-16 18:38

    Lmao your hero is here to call you out on your dogmatic Luddite stance and you lot just outright reject him. Absolutely delicious.

    Open ##5066696

  • @SrMono@feddit.org 2026-10-16 18:56

    Good lord, he isn’t even a programmer or computer scientist, but I’m glad he has an opinion.

    Open ##5067002

  • @redbrick@lemmy.world 2026-10-16 18:57

    When can we get an OS truly developed by AI? …like ground up from Claude or OpenAI?

    Open ##5067009

  • @DjangoFett@lemmy.zip 2026-10-16 18:59

    My last use of AI is in my post history and was fairly down voted because I was being foolishly ironic. This said, I don’t really disagree with his take here despite keeping away from AI as much as I am reasonably able. I do my own critical thinking and hate that I have to jump through hoops on the internet to have a simple question answered without some layman’s AI summary that may or may not be even remotely correct or actionable. Even still, when I asked it to check on local real estate laws and provide summaries of possible actions based on a very strict set of parameters, it gave me information that my wife and I were able to bring to a human agent and have things work out better than we had actually expected. I think a better way of putting it - and I’m still gonna ruffle feathers - is that AI is becoming the new electricity. Put down your pitchfork and lemme explain. When electricity came out, people rather reasonably pointed out that simply coming into contact with an electrical device could result in death if one wasn’t careful. On top of that, the infrastructure required for it was expensive, unsightly, and at the time incredibly disruptive to daily life. It was going to ruin and disrupt entire industries that had existed for centuries because it could do things a human could not do unaided. All of this is to one degree or another entirely true even through to modern times, but electricity has become a ubiquitous resource that humanity would now deeply struggle to live without. I won’t dare compare AI that far as i genuinely believe humans would be significantly better off without it, but the initial Luddite response to electricity has a historical echo here. I think Linus’ point is more that it can undoubtedly be a useful tool when used in a measured, controlled, intelligent manner, and that it is a genie that is very clearly unwilling to be put back in its bottle. Like it or not it exists, and while we can absolutely be unhappy about it, being blind to its actual real world beneficial uses because the companies that make it are actual festering waste is a bit silly - especially when in the hands of the right chaotic neutral parties these companies are about to have a massive lesson in just how messy their tools have made things.

    Open ##5067125

  • I have mixed opinions on his stance towards AI. I confess, I’m guilty. I’ve used AI to diagnose random issues with my little personal blog (please don’t hate me, I’m just a man without a degree). That said, I understood the simple code well enough to see what I was getting wrong and comprehend the AI generated suggestion, so it wasn’t all that different than looking things up on a wiki and implementing it. The primary difference, for me, was that I had already spent two weeks digging deeper and deeper for my answers, only finding outdated or incorrect information, and Claude delivered the correct answer in about 10 seconds. In my opinion, the reason it was a good idea to implement the AI generated code was that I understood it. There was a human brain looking at that result and going “aha! I see what I was missing!” If I hadn’t understood what I was looking at, it could have been doing anything, and I wouldn’t have felt comfortable implementing it. If I hadn’t at least tried to the old fashioned way first, I wouldn’t have used it. But after weeks of hitting dead ends and with the knowledge that there was an extremely powerful tool that could give me my answer in seconds, it began to feel foolish to continue punishing myself with wasted time. In Linus’ case, I think it is safe to say he understands enough about Linux to interpret the AI suggestions and be a safeguard against slop. I’m not too concerned about his contributions to the kernel if he’s using AI to think outside the box or diagnose a complicated problem. But! There is a major risk factor when people start implementing code that they don’t understand, or when it is a crutch for their total lack of comprehension. Vibe coding and using a diagnostic tool are different things. I hope Linus gives some real thought to the realistic limits that need to be in place for people who aren’t knowledgeable enough to filter AI suggested code through their own brains, because it wouldn’t take long to destroy a reliable system like Linux if they incorporate AI generated code with no experienced human in the drivers seat. Apologies to those who just fundamentally hate AI and think I’m a fool for using it, I just wanted to share my experience as an unschooled computer nerd who finally gave in and tried it out a couple of times.

    Open ##5067158

  • Man, that’s a shame It’s one thing to think AI is good. It’s another to call others stupid for rejecting it

    Open ##5067950

  • @davel@lemmy.ml 2026-10-16 19:25

    When the topic is AI, the quality of some of these Lemmy threads drops down to the level of YouTube comments.

    Open ##5068027

  • @Shimitar@downonthestreet.eu 2026-10-16 19:29

    Fully agree with Linux. Ai is a tool. Learn how to properly use it or not use it like you prefer, it’s a goddamn tool. If you are a bad coder you will still be a bad coder using AI. If you are a good coder, you will be a faster good coder with AI. It’s a fucking tool.

    Open ##5068051

  • @Cysioland@lemmygrad.ml 2026-10-16 19:48

    heartbreaking: this Finnish nationalist is saying some good stuff

    Open ##5068245

  • @Tattorack@lemmy.world 2026-10-16 19:58

    Slop harder, Torvalds. You fucking lost it, and you’re ruining Linux for everyone. At least the other kernel maintainers still check things and catch problems, because clearly Linus Torvalds doesn’t care anymore and would rather make false equivalence excuses.

    Open ##5068329

  • @chloroken@lemmy.ml 2026-10-16 19:58

    Linus Torvalds is not an intelligent person. His argument style is extremely feeble, propped up solely from the ulterior and omnipresent appeal to authority. He created some awesome software. Git, Linux. But the dude should have been kicked out of Linux dev a while ago. He is no longer required, and just runs his mouth constantly.

    Open ##5068348

  • @danielquinn@lemmy.ca 2026-10-16 20:07

    Does he… think LLMs are deterministic?

    Open ##5068435

  • @Mondez@lemdro.id 2026-10-16 20:10

    What is stupid is referring to AI as if it was just one tool when actually it’s a bunch of tools, some of which are easier to use sensibly amd some it’s near impossible to. Fancy auto complete like it’s being compared to sure, fully automated do what the fuck you want agents, yeah sooner or later that is going to go wrong and no one is going to know where or why. They might be fun and interesting, that doesn’t make it a great idea to go all in in my opinion, certainly not for anything you would consider important.

    Open ##5068474

  • @uszo165@futurology.today 2026-10-16 20:14

    He really thinks the tools you use do not shape and limit your results and yourself. I’d take a book carefully crafted in LaTeX anytime over slop pasted from Copilot into Word. What he’s not even seeing is that AI is, above all, a source of input. No other tool, not the best LaTeX editor, takes care of my writing. AI is totally different. It is the author of Linus’ code, it is his ghostwriter. He did not write it. He should not claim authorship. If he’s not the author, he can’t legally release it as Free software under a GNU license.

    Open ##5068539

  • Open ##5068733

  • @jaycifer@lemmy.world 2026-10-16 20:21

    My understanding is that AI/LLMs can generate code that works, but often that code is more bloated/convoluted than code written by a decent coder, making it less efficient and more difficult to maintain. I can see that being acceptable for many in situations where hardware/performance/maintainability aren’t a concern like a one-off app or proof of concept. But for something as low level as a kernel I would think that performance and maintainability are the most important things since slowdown in that part of the system ripples up to affect everything a user does anywhere in the operating system. I understand that a skilled coder can take AI output and clean it up into something at least approaching the quality of their own unassisted code, and I’ve been led to believe that Linus is able to do that for himself. But I fear that other/future maintainers of Linux won’t match that caliber, and it will start to feel that AI bloat. I think I’ve also read of Linus complaining about a torrent of low-quality, AI-based submissions and so I also fear that this will lead to him restricting who can participate in the work, overcompensate, and end up in a situation where Linux becomes less open and more closed.

    Open ##5068734

  • @cypherpunks@lemmy.ml 2026-10-16 21:28

    here is the email this screenshot is an excerpt of; the specific “X” (which the message Linus is replying to here suggested perhaps AI should not be used for) was the writing of commit messages.

    Open ##5070298

  • @brucethemoose@lemmy.world 2026-10-16 21:35

    The other practical side of this is enforceability. Lets say Linux banned all use of VSCode in contributions, this second. And any Microsoft tools. No exceptions. And it makes sense, because there is an evil blatantly anti-linux entity behind it… What are people gonna do? Keep using it anyway, and just not disclose it. This is why linux doesn’t tell people what tools they can and can’t use. Just like they don’t try to police who contributes to the kernel, much. Other contributors don’t have to like it, but that is how a project like this must operate.

    Open ##5070396

  • @flandish@lemmy.world 2026-10-16 21:37

    the thing is - no other tool in our industry, and others, out there involves as much active destruction in both the working class and environment in its use. that’s it. that’s the bit.

    Open ##5070410

  • Cory Doctorow’s “Reverse Centaurs Guide to Life After AI” has a short section that pertains to this. He talks about how someone like Linus essentially doesn’t have a boss and has untold resources for whatever “AI” “tools” he finds useful. He isn’t ever forced to use the wrong tool for the job or use a tool that simply doesn’t do what his boss thinks it does. He doesn’t have to worry about getting fired or his coworkers getting fired because his boss was sold a story about reducing labor costs with this cool new “tool”. He simply uses what’s useful to him with the probably millions of dollars of compute made available to him by the tech giants. 95% of people don’t have that luxury. They have a boss itching to get rid of them or 10x their workload with the help of the “tool” that Linus is so happily and defiantly praising on behalf of the monopolists.

    Open ##5070773

  • @melfie@lemmy.zip 2026-10-16 22:50

    Maybe the rule should be that if you use AI, just make sure Linus can’t tell you did.

    Open ##5071143

  • AI is just a tool, the user of a tool should be competent enough to use it properly

    Open ##5071474

  • @AceFuzzLord@lemmy.zip 2026-10-16 23:24

    new and interesting tools Looks Under The Generative AI Hood Sees Snakeoil Salesman Selling Labotomies As The Future

    Open ##5071561

  • @likebudda@reddthat.com 2026-10-16 23:53

    I don’t have a personal or professional workflow that would benefit from AI. I have not been impressed with any generated art or writing (knowingly, so far). I pretty much only know it for the enshittification of search results. It might be great at coding, I’ll never know because in my first 49 years of life I’ve only needed to code enough to get a D+ in my Pascal class. It might get great at generating art but I haven’t had to generate art since my sophomore year of high school. I hear it’s good at scanning lab test results which is great for future me when I need a lab test result but doesn’t come up for me in the day-to-day. There are plenty of other useful things I’m sure it can do for other people but the stuff they say it can do for me right now is nothing I’m interested in having done for me.

    Open ##5071915

  • @Doomsider@lemmy.world 2026-10-17 00:05

    I like Linus, but comparing an LLM to a compiler is fucking stupid.

    Open ##5071969

  • @manuallybreathing@lemmy.ml 2026-10-17 00:23

    01000100 01101111 01101110 01110100 00100000 01000000 00100000 01101101 01100101 00100000 01101001 01100110 00100000 01111001 01101111 01110101 00100000 01100011 01100001 01101110 01110100 00100000 01110010 01100101 01110011 01110000 01101111 01101110 01100100 00100000 01101001 01101110 00100000 01100010 01101001 01101110 01100001 01110010 01111001 *01110011 01110000 01101111 01101001 01101100 01100101 01110010* Dont @ me if you cant respond in binary

    Open ##5072186

  • @uriel238@lemmy.blahaj.zone 2026-10-17 00:49

    Every once in a while I’ll ask the DDG AI a question, and then try to confirm ot with narrower searches. I think that’s the extent of my use of LLMs. And I feel guilty for it, wondering how much water and power it’s taking and if the compute is poisoning the air of its human neighbors and keeping them up at night with a 70 dB hum. There might be something to be said about using models locally, and using them as part of a human-guided process. Note: I’ve stopped calling it AI in favor of LLM, partly due to the whole SI controversy in the US and partly in the hope that AI is still a larger category of learning systems that might lead to AGI, if we don’t destroy ourselves first. Also the Jev model looks like an interesting development that indicates the ultimate tools might be other than a later model from OpenAI or Anthropic. Note Also: I programmed in the 1990s and broke my brain trying to teach a computer to competently play a complex strategy game. I got pretty far before all my variable names leaked out of my head. These days, I write simple AHK scripts but that’s about it. So I’m way out of my league when it comes to sound 2020s era coding methods.

    Open ##5072487

  • I think if I had taken an icecream scoop to my forebrain I would have experienced more intellectual development than reading the contributions of the sloppers. You all need to read about enclosure and learn to make arguments without analogy.

    Open ##5072600

  • @Mniot@programming.dev 2026-10-17 01:55

    I’m kind of gobsmacked by this. I’ve heard younger developers compare LLM with compiler and chalked it up to ignorance, but I don’t get what this is. Can I write code in assembly? Yes. Of course. It’s true that I never do it, but if there was a rule that you needed to write some assembly now and then to certify as a kernel developer I don’t see how it would be any kind of impediment. Comparing more directly: if you hand me a compiled binary and the source code and ask “why is the bit at address 0xXXXXXXXXX a 0?” I can, with 100% certainty, answer that. Probably in less than a day of effort. If I ask "why did the LLM output “for” as the XXXXth word of its utterance, can Linus say why? And “can you write a good commit message without an editor?” Uhhh? At least when I was in school, this was something people did for fun/messing around. I still do cat > somefile when I need to put some quick text together. In fact, Claude will sometimes write a Git commit by cat-ing into a file–which it’s doing because there’s so many online examples of this. Fucking weird things for Linus to pick. Makes me think his brain’s rotted.

    Open ##5073411

  • @KullumDaue@lemmy.world 2026-10-17 05:32

    why the highlights?

    Open ##5078275

  • @bertlewirth@lemy.lol 2026-10-17 06:09

    sigh. I think it’s time to move to a BSD. Linus is gone.

    Open ##5078492

  • @SaharaMaleikuhm@feddit.org 2026-10-17 06:20

    AI psychosis. Someone put him out of his misery.

    Open ##5078566

  • @heartSagan5@lemmy.zip 2026-10-17 06:34

    … is that people do their best and I expect people to understand what they are doing. Except you can’t with AI. It vomits a black box, and you have to decode it and test it before dumping it in a commit. Few do that.

    Open ##5078623

  • @butsbutts@lemmy.ml 2026-10-17 07:01

    hes comparing knowing how open concepts work vs using proprietary tech whose purpose is to hook you and then enshittify after you become reliant on it

    Open ##5078802

  • @drmoose@lemmy.world 2026-10-17 07:44

    Can’t help but laugh at you guys correcting literally the #1 software maintainer in the world. AI is just a tool - if you fail then it’s a skill issue.

    Open ##5078960

  • @Drun@lemmy.world 2026-10-17 08:21

    Based.

    Open ##5079390